For every group of albums presented pick the ones you like more than the other ones. Eventually you'll wittle it down to your very favourite, who will then appear in the "Found Favourites" section. Keep going to make a top albums list of whatever length you like. There's no prescribed criteria, feel free to base your list on your own personal taste. I picked this based on top album lists from various publications, music websites like RYM and AOTY, best sellers and award winners.
Click Below for more details on how it works
If you want a more detailed explanation, it works by keeping track of which albums eliminate other artsts. Once those are added to the found favourites list every album that album eliminated returns to the pool. This means as long as you pick consistently you should have a perfect list of what your GOATs are. The pass button just keeps all of the current crop in the pool, so it's useful if you see a selection you don't have an opinion about. Also, you can reorder your list afterwards by dragging your picks around, just in case you made a mistake.
This is a full on rip off of the favorite Pokemon picker by Cave of Dragonflies. She put all the code on github for anyone to use so massive shouts out. The original idea was to make a better alternative to bracket tournaments. Those work fine for finding your one singular favourite but everything after that is heavily dependant on seeding (i.e. in a bracket if your two favourites are pitted against each other in the first round then one of your favourites even wouldn't even make the top 10). So anyway, I hope you enjoy finding your GOATs!!!
AOTY Best Albums of All Time by User Score
Wikipedia: List of Best-Selling Albums
Wikipedia: List of best-selling albums by year in the United States
Rolling Stones 500 Greatest Albums of All Time
Pitchfork Readers 200 Best Albums of the Last 25 Years
Paste The 300 Greatest Albums of All Time
Musictaste Top Albums of All Time